Collistar Eyeliner Shock Eyeliner

I am very satisfied with this eyeliner, and this is not the first time I am purchasing it. I read somewhere that it smudges on the eyelid, but I haven't experienced that, perhaps because I apply eyeshadow beforehand. The quality is good, and the color is a vibrant black.

Terrible eyeliner! After a couple of hours, it smudges and transfers onto the upper eyelid ((( I've been using Ardeco eyeliners for 5 years, and they have never let me down. I bought this eyeliner as a birthday gift for myself, and I regret it deeply!

The eyeliner is excellent. It does not smudge or dry out. It is very convenient to use, and the application is precise without requiring much effort.

Thin, easily adjustable, long-lasting, I am satisfied.

Good, slim marker.

Yes, I agree. It is beautiful, but the minute hand keeps breaking and I can't fix it. It's even worse now. I bought it at the department store, but I won't buy it there anymore. It's a pity for the money I spent.

Well, how can I put it? At first, it paints pretty well, but then it becomes a bit heavy. It feels like applying a silicone-like substance that doesn't go on smoothly. The brush tends to break, making it difficult to achieve a precise application. When trying to redo a stroke, it becomes cumbersome and messy. Overall, Dior is much better, so I won't be buying this one again. It's a bit complicated to apply.