Benefit Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner كحل ماتي للعين

does not smudge, the brush is top-notch

This eyeliner pleasantly surprised me. It is a very convenient marker that allows for easy application of winged eyeliner. It does not smudge or create a mess on the lashes during application. The eyeliner applies evenly and has a slight glossy finish. It is suitable for beginners who are not yet skilled at creating precise winged lines. The only thing I found lacking was the intensity of the black color, but it was only a minor issue. Additionally, the marker cannot create as thin lines as a brush, but this difference will only be noticeable to experienced artists. It lasts the whole day, until late evening, without leaving any smudges. It does not crumble or smear. I applied it on top of an eyelid base. It is definitely worth the money and I highly recommend giving it a try, you won't be disappointed.

I bought this product in Europe and I really liked it. It is easy to use and the black color is very intense. It stays on well, but the price is quite high.

I bought this eyeliner from a well-known store in Poland, but it feels like I got it from a granny in the market for 50 hryvnias:(( It smudges a lot, not long-lasting, and by the end of the day, I have panda-like circles under my eyes.