Catrice Calligraph Pro Precise 24h Matt Liner Waterproof كحل مقاوم للماء

I bought two of these eyeliners, with delivery from the EU, but they arrived without any packaging film! Now I can't use them because I'm not sure if they are new or not.

The eyeliner arrived without the protective film, but I didn't pay much attention to it. I opened it and there was no eyeliner inside! The felt brush is dry, and it left some marks on my hand when I pressed down hard, but there's absolutely nothing on my eyelids. It feels like a waste of money, with futile expectations and hope - especially since it was shipped from Europe.

A decent eyeliner. The brush is really great, thin but not stiff or too soft. Compared to the Evelyn one in the golden packaging, I prefer this one more.

I bought it from a different store and I want to leave a review.
I got three of them, hoping at least one would be suitable. From the photos, you can understand which one is better.
1. Catrice "Calligraphy" - black, matte finish, 10/10. Waterproof and dries instantly.
2. Eveline "Art Makeup" - black, not matte, with a golden shimmer! It looks like they already applied gold eyeshadow on top of the black eyeliner. I'm not sure if I'll use it.
3. Eveline "Variete" - black, not matte, glossy finish, waterproof.

I highly recommend this eyeliner, it can withstand anything. I especially recommend it for girls in relationships.

The waterproof eyeliner worked great and applied evenly for a month. However, after that, the tip completely dried out and became bent, making it impossible to apply any more makeup.

This eyeliner is not waterproof at all, so I have to touch up my winged eyeliner throughout the day. However, it does apply beautifully.

Vibrant color, convenient liner, but not long-lasting at all. Within two hours, it all smudged.

For me, this is the perfect eyeliner.

Good quality.