Vivienne Sabo Charbon Liquid Eyeliner

I am writing a review after using the entire bottle.
The eyeliner lasted a long time, I used it once every 1-2 days for about a year. The eyeliner is long-lasting, does not smudge, but towards the end of the day, it starts to crack and flake.
However, there is one downside that makes me hesitant to repurchase it now - occasionally, after applying it, it stings on the eyelids. Therefore, I do not recommend it.

Perhaps, for this money, one can learn to live with it. However, there is a feeling of tightness. The brush is too thick and not very suitable for precise lines.

I generally liked the eyeliner. In the first few days, I did feel a slight tightness, but it quickly went away. Now I apply it and everything is fine.

The eyeliner is great. The delivery was fast. The quality is superb. The brush is really good. Thanks to the courier.

This eyeliner is my love. The brush is thin and dense, making it very convenient for drawing precise lines. It doesn't smudge or flake and has a matte finish.

I am satisfied with this eyeliner! It stays perfectly in place all day, even though I have oily skin.

The eyeliner is simply disappointing. It has absolutely no staying power. If your eye suddenly tears up, it immediately smudges. You constantly have to touch it up throughout the day. I used it for a week and threw it away. It's just a waste of money.

It's visually unappealing, falls short in performance, not a brush but just a stick - words fail me, it's all emotions. I will definitely never order it again.

I ordered this product based on good reviews and now I'm confused. The eyeliner has a good consistency, applies nicely, and has a comfortable handle and brush for drawing. I bought it and I'm happy!
However..
On the second day of use, I had to touch up my eyes three times because the line kept smudging + it had a burning sensation when applied. When it started to slightly burn my eyelid again on the third day, I decided to remove and throw it away to avoid any harm to my eye.

I liked it, but it takes some getting used to the brush. It stays in place well and allows for precise lines to be drawn.

Intense black color. Layering is not possible as it cracks and flakes over time.

My favorite eyeliner, based on a recommendation, I bought it a few years ago and still only purchase it.

This eyeliner is amazing, my favorite. It took me a while to get used to the very stiff applicator, BUT in the end, I believe that this type of applicator is actually a positive feature.

I didn't buy it here, but the eyeliner is very watery. It holds up fairly well, but you need to apply two coats.

BEST MASCARA I'VE EVER USED IN MY ENTIRE LIFE!

This is my absolute favorite eyeliner. It is extremely long-lasting, vibrant, and easy to apply.

I have been using this eyeliner for probably two years now. It stays on well throughout the day. By the end, I only need to touch up the tips of the wing. The only thing I don't like (maybe it's just me) is that even when I apply powder under the eyeliner, it still becomes shiny after a couple of hours, and I would prefer the wings to be matte all day. What's great is that if water gets on the wings, they don't smudge or run, they stay put (as long as you don't rub them and let them dry naturally, of course).

The application is uneven, so an additional layer is required. There is a burning sensation until it dries, but then it's fine. The advantages are: it holds well and does not crumble.

I don't know what girls used before purchasing this "miracle" to write so many positive reviews. But for me, this eyeliner is simply terrible. It dries out faster than you can finish applying it and doesn't go on evenly. It's inconsistent overall. To be honest, I absolutely disliked it. I bought another one and threw this one away without any regrets.

The eyeliner is just like any other eyeliner. The brush dries out quickly while applying, so you have to constantly dip it back into the bottle. It applies smoothly and stays on well. The color is a rich, intense black.

The formula itself is actually quite good, delivering a rich black color that dries down to a perfect matte finish. However, the brush is something else entirely. It's stiff, which would normally be a plus, but unfortunately, it's also huge and thick. :( It's nearly impossible to achieve thin lines with it, unless you use a brush from another product. Aside from that, the eyeliner formula is really good.

It seems to be good, but it burns the eyelid afterwards... I even feel like it slightly swells.

This eyeliner is truly MATTE. It stays on very well and applies neatly.

I really liked the eyeliner. The brush is firm, which is more convenient for me than a soft one. It's easier to draw a precise line, like using a pencil. The color is sharp and black. I highly recommend it!

Excellent eyeliner, long-lasting, convenient brush. Very satisfied with it!

The brush turned out to be very inconvenient for me, making it difficult to apply proper winged eyeliner.

I believe that for such a price, this eyeliner is excellent. The brush is actually quite stiff, but if you're used to applying winged eyeliner every day, you adapt to it pretty quickly. However, if you prefer thinner lines, it's better to choose an eyeliner with a softer brush. Overall, I really like this eyeliner.

After reading the reviews, I decided to give it a try, but unfortunately, I was disappointed. The brush is really stiff, and when I apply it, it actually burns my eyelid. Well, at least for me, I have sensitive skin. When I apply a thick layer, it tends to crack and by the evening, it may start to flake off a bit. Also, if I apply a thinner layer, the color appears more gray than black.

For this price, the eyeliner is simply perfect. It goes on easily, stays well, doesn't smudge, and doesn't run.

Simply perfect, this brush is convenient. Contrary to what many say, it's not stiff or impractical, I disagree. This eyeliner is meant for those who love to cry and always remain on top. It survived tears (well, if you don't rub your eyes, any long-lasting makeup will come off) and rainstorms and sleep.

Long-lasting eyeliner with a convenient brush. I wonder how long it will last, but overall it is wonderful for its price.

The best eyeliner I've ever used in my life, I've already ordered it for the fourth time. It completely satisfies me, even with irregular use, it lasts for 3-4 months. Makeup, as always, pleases with fast delivery and high-quality cosmetics.

This eyeliner is great for its price. The brush is firm, which is exactly what I like. It smudges if you rub your eyes, but otherwise, it lasts all day long.

I have tried many different eyeliners. So far, this one is the best for me. I am satisfied.

Overall, it is better suited for drawing thick arrows. However, the eyeliner itself is actually quite good. I would give it a solid four out of five.

Terrible eyeliner.
Bought it based on rave reviews and regretted it.
It dries on the skin and becomes more greyish.
Drawing a line is impossible, the brush leaves streaks and you have to try to cover it up with several layers.
And even then, it doesn't always work.
The brush itself is stiff, perhaps even too much.
It's a bit painful on delicate skin.
Such a waste of money.

I fell in love with this eyeliner! I used to use a different brand, but this one surpasses it. It doesn't peel off in layers. By the evening, it may crack a little, but it doesn't come off completely. It easily washes off with a foaming cleanser or toner. It dries quickly and becomes matte.

I really need this brown one! I hope there will be an opportunity for me to buy it from you.

I have been using this product for about 3 years now and it is amazing. Not only does it have a sturdy brush that allows me to create precise, fine lines, but it also becomes matte after some time, giving it a more expensive appearance.

I ordered the eyeliner based on a makeup artist's recommendation. It's good, long-lasting, and has an intense black color. I love the firm brush! But!!! I waited for over a week for my order, even though I paid for the product in full. I ended up canceling two orders because they never actually prepared my order, as they told me over the phone. It's impossible to reach their customer hotline. I didn't expect to encounter such problems. I am unsatisfied with the service. After lengthy email exchanges and complaints, four representatives from the website finally contacted me. It takes a long time to get them to send the paid order.

The lasting power of the eyeliner is good. However, it takes some time to get used to the brush as it is quite firm.

My first eyeliner was not a felt-tip pen. It turned out to be really cool. The lines are straight, perfect, and matte. At first, I couldn't get used to this way of drawing lines, but then I learned and now I do it every day. It doesn't crumble or smudge.

I purchased this brand's eyeliner for the first time. I am very satisfied with its quality, although it takes some time to get used to the brush. It applies excellently without smudging on the eyelid and effectively colors the space between the lashes. The eyeliner doesn't crack throughout the day. Thank you so much, MAKEUP! The delivery was very fast, and the courier will find you wherever you are, whether at work or at home :)

I have been using this eyeliner for 4 years and I don't want to switch. It allows you to draw both thick and thin lines, you just need to get used to the brush.

The makeup has completely deteriorated! They are offering discounts on cosmetics that are nearing their expiration date!!!! I have no questions about the product itself, but they could at least warn about such "waste of money." It's better to buy from brick-and-mortar stores where you can see what you're getting.

I prefer this eyeliner, it's my must-have. With it, I can quickly draw precise and vibrant wings. It lasts for six months even with daily use.

I purchased this product as part of a set with mascara. The eyeliner is terrible. It is impossible to draw thin lines with it. I tried using a brush, but when I apply the product, the line appears semi-transparent. When I try to go over the line again, the skin stretches and the line becomes jagged. I will definitely throw away this eyeliner; it's not even worth giving it to anyone as a gift.

Awful eyeliner. I used to love it, but now its quality has deteriorated significantly. I didn't buy it here.

Intensely black with a matte finish, it is long-lasting - it can handle anything. I have been using only this product for 8 years. The only downside is that the felt brush doesn't allow for thin lines. So, when I want thin lines, I use a different brush, but when I want thicker lines, the original brush does the job. It doesn't take long to dry. I highly recommend it.

I do understand that the expiration date is 30 months, but the manufacturing date of 09.2017 somehow concerns me.