Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

I don't know, but my review disappeared, so I'm duplicating it.

This mascara is not waterproof. It washed off from the tips after 3 times of washing with warm water, even though I bought it for swimming in the pool. As a result, I had panda eyes and black particles underneath my eyes, as well as residue on my lashes. It washed off easily with regular makeup remover. It applies nicely, doesn't crumble or clump.

It might be suitable for protecting against rain, snow, and tears, but not for swimming. Maybe someone can recommend a truly waterproof mascara?

The mascara arrived almost empty! I wasted 300 UAH for nothing!

I have been buying this mascara not for the first time, and I really like it. The only drawback is that it dries out after 4 months. However, the quality is superb, and I have no issues swimming in the pool with it.

I didn't buy it here, but I am satisfied with the product. It doesn't spill, clump, or smudge on the eyelids. It easily and effortlessly removes with a two-phase makeup remover, even without leaving streaks.

I enjoy mascaras that make my lashes voluminous and separate each hair. This one is not specifically designed for that, but I fell for the advertisement and bought it. It does give wow-worthy length, which would be suitable for those who like that, but I didn't like it. It tends to clump the lashes a bit, but if you comb them with a clean brush, it looks okay. However, it dries out the skin under the eyes and flakes off, so I definitely won't buy it again. By the way, it works much better on fake lashes.

I don't understand the hype about this mascara. If you're looking for volume, this is not the right product for you. It is more focused on separating the lashes, but when you try to layer it, it clumps up and is difficult to remove.

Overall, the mascara is not bad. The brush effectively separates the lashes, but unfortunately, the mascara itself leaves smudges under the eyes. I will not be purchasing it again.

I purchased it on August 3rd. And today, it is only October 14th, and the mascara has already dried out. I use it to coat my lashes daily. But this time, I am disappointed. I spent 300 UAH for just two months..... Now I will try buying it at the market to compare.

If you are looking for volume, I do not recommend this mascara. It separates and lengthens nicely, but it lacks in providing volume. However, it does stay on well, does not smudge, and is difficult to remove.

Has Maybelline changed their formula or something? Because this mascara arrived as if it had been used for a couple of months already. No packaging or seal - okay, I understand that's the manufacturer's fault. But the consistency is very dry. I didn't feel at all that this was a new mascara. I compared it to the Loreal mascara that I had been using for 4 months, and the effect of Loreal is better (by effect, I mean how much it lengthens the lashes, how "easily" it applies, and the pigmentation). In short, I'm disappointed :(

The best mascara in my life! I have been using it for about 2 years. Everyone complains that it is impossible to remove, but thanks to the hydrophilic oil it is easy to wash off. It amazingly curls and lengthens the lashes, and the applicator is fantastic. I highly recommend it from the bottom of my heart!

The mascara is indeed waterproof, lengthens lashes, and overall looks great on the eyes. However, removing it is a nightmare! I struggle to remove it with an oil-based micellar water. It has broken all my lashes.

I received the mascara without any packaging. In other words, it could have been opened at any time and already dried out. Seriously, what kind of makeup is this?

I haven't ordered from you in a year because I barely recovered from my last order, which took several weeks to arrive without any notification.

Okay, you fixed the delivery issue, but what about the packaging? I haven't tested the mascara yet, so I will provide further updates later.

I bought this mascara because of the great reviews, but the reality turned out to be different. The only positive thing is that it incredibly lengthens lashes and is very long-lasting. However, the consistency of the mascara is terrible (it might be suitable for those who like spider legs), but I prefer when my lashes are separated. It is very difficult to apply with the original brush, and it doesn't comb well with others.

The mascara is amazing! I have been searching for a mascara for sensitive eyes and oily skin that doesn't smudge or flake onto my contact lenses for years. I agree with the other girls that it is difficult to remove, but I switched from micellar water to a makeup remover specifically designed for waterproof mascara, and the problem was solved. It applies easily and stays on all day without any issues. I have no complaints.

It does not crumble, easily washes off with foamy washbasins, but since it is new, small clumps stick together. It beautifully lengthens the eyelashes.

It is simply impossible to remove it. Neither micellar water nor hydrophilic oil can do the job. A nightmare.

I really liked this mascara. It applies smoothly and doesn't clump my lashes. It's perfect! The design is fantastic.

Rinsing completely - it's unreal.

I absolutely love this mascara. I have been using it for over 2 years, and no other mascara has been able to replace it. It removes just as it should, like a waterproof mascara should be removed.

The product arrived unsealed.
The appearance of the product is strange, and it still leaves traces under the eyes, making me look like a raccoon.
Overall, it is a complete disappointment.

This product is very good, I highly recommend it.

Good mascara! The brush is convenient and it coats the lashes well. Usually, waterproof mascaras are very liquid at first, for the first couple of weeks, but this one has a good consistency right away. It is very easy to remove with a two-phase makeup remover.

The only good thing about it is that it is long-lasting. However, the brush is terrible as it clumps and makes the lashes stick out in different directions. I have to use the brush from my old mascara instead.

This mascara is excellent. It doesn't smudge, flake, or fear rain/snow/pool water. It easily washes off with a two-phase makeup remover (just like any other waterproof mascara). While it is still very fresh, I always wipe the brush on a tissue before applying it to my lashes. This helps to avoid the spider leg effect.

This is a great waterproof mascara that is perfect for winter or extremely hot summers. The only downside is that it arrived a bit dry and without any packaging.

This mascara is simply terrible. I don't think it could get any worse. I'm only giving it one star because it's waterproof, but that's also its downside since it's almost impossible to remove from my lashes. Neither milk, nor micellar water, nor cleanser can get rid of this mascara. The only way is to mechanically scrape it off my lashes, which results in pulling out half of them. This is the perfect example of what a mascara should not be.

I really liked this mascara - it has a good volume and consistency, and it doesn't smudge.

I made a mistake and ordered the waterproof one (
It doesn't wash off at all, it's ruined all my lashes((
As for the mascara, it's just average to be honest. It clumps the lashes together and after a few strokes, it creates spider-like lashes. I can buy a mascara like this for 70 UAH, but it definitely doesn't worth 240 UAH...

I haven't used it yet, but the mascara is not tightly sealed or packaged with anything.

The mascara is really cool, it lengthens the lashes, and it is waterproof.

This mascara is absolutely amazing.

I really liked this mascara! It doesn't clump or smudge, the brush is great, it applies and separates the lashes nicely. Many people thought I had extensions, but when they found out it was just mascara without any lash extensions, they couldn't believe it and asked which mascara I use for coloring.

Waterproof and doesn't smudge, that's all I can say as a positive. The mascara from Vivienne Sabo is better and cheaper. I was very disappointed from the first glance. The packaging is the cheapest plastic. There is no packaging or protection, so you can't even be sure that nobody used it before you. The dispenser popped out after +/-2 weeks. There is a lot of advertising, but in reality, it's just okay... I won't be buying it again.
No complaints about the makeup. They are always on point.

This product is indeed waterproof, it does not smudge or leak. However, it should be noted that it dries very quickly, so there won't be an opportunity to fix anything (unless you separate the lashes) or apply a second coat, as it will result in clumps. But if you have experience, there shouldn't be any issues.
The cone-shaped silicone brush is very convenient and allows for precise application in the corners.
There is a similar non-waterproof version available, which is easier to work with.

I'm buying this mascara for the second time. One of its advantages is that it's really long-lasting. That's about it. I do like it, but I only bought it for the longevity. A significant drawback is the application, it's quite difficult to apply several layers without it looking clumpy because it dries very quickly. You have to distribute the product very precisely from the start (there's no point in trying to fix anything later). For me, it's perfect for "natural makeup" in just one layer and it lasts all day, even after tears or swimming. So, I'm satisfied with the purchase. I remove it with regular micellar water for waterproof makeup and my lashes remain in good condition.

Good waterproof mascara.

"I really liked this product, it's a useful thing to have in your cosmetics bag. However, it's not suitable for everyday use. The mascara is waterproof, so it's difficult to remove, but that's also the purpose of it. I usually remove it with hot water and facial cleanser, sometimes I also use micellar water. My expectations were confirmed."

I recommend not applying a second layer because it dries quickly. I liked it. I remove it with the makeup remover for eyes and lips from L'Oreal Paris. It doesn't crumble and my eyelashes don't fall out. I recommend it.

I did not buy it here, but I will leave a review for the girls. This version is different not only in terms of its lasting power compared to the usual one, but also incredibly fast drying on the lashes. So, you apply it once, maybe twice if you're lucky, and then it's all set. If something was not even before, there are almost no chances to fix it. I have long lashes, so when it all dries, you end up tearing apart these lashes in attempts to fix something, and it also clumps and creates lumps. In short, this version is only suitable for a healthy mind or for those who enjoy complicated paths. The only thing you can definitely do with it is cry, as if you've made spider legs, sat down, and cried))

Sorry, but this product is terrible. It is the worst mascara from Maybelline I have ever used. It doesn't do anything - it doesn't curl, add volume, or layer well. The only positive is that it is definitely waterproof, but removing it is a challenge. I do not recommend wasting your money on it.

This mascara is great, the silicone brush is very convenient and it doesn't smudge on the eyelid. Of course, you need to remove it with a two-phase makeup remover for waterproof cosmetics.
Ladies, if you notice that too much product accumulates on the brush from the tube, make sure to wipe the brush on a dry tissue. This way, you'll avoid clumpy lashes and achieve beautifully coated ones. This technique is recommended for any new mascara to avoid excessive application and clumping of the lashes.

It really stays well, but it only applies a maximum of 2-3 coats. Otherwise, everything clumps together and turns into spider-leg-like clumps. I applied it over another mascara to prevent the tips of my lashes from smudging onto my eyelids.

Good mascara, cannot be washed off easily. It stays on well, but it didn't suit me personally as it clumped everything together. I tried to separate it, but too much product came out on the brush. I don't regret trying it, but it dried up in the packaging very quickly. I won't be buying it again next time.

I didn't buy it here. I have no complaints about the website, but the mascara is terrible. I fell for the advertisement. Don't buy it if you don't want to be left without lashes. It looks cheap. It incredibly clumps the lashes. The waterproof feature is good, but then it is impossible to remove even with a special remover, leaving many of your own lashes on the cotton pad after it. The brush is too flexible, so while you're applying the mascara, everything around your eyes gets dirty. It only lengthens like a regular mascara. The lashes look bad, clumped together, and there is no curl. The lashes end up straight and glued together, impossible to remove. I don't understand why everyone recommends it.

I really like this mascara. I bought it based on the reviews from this website. The waterproof effect has been tested with heavy snow and tears. I even received a compliment, "Are those your natural lashes?" It's a shame that someone didn't appreciate this mascara or that something isn't right with it. There may be some water droplets from the mascara on my lashes, but it doesn't bother me because now I have this mascara! )))) However, a regular micellar water couldn't remove it. Then I read on the website reviews and bought the L'Oreal two-phase waterproof makeup remover. Now everything is super! I'm satisfied.

I wouldn't recommend buying it. It was a complete disappointment. There is too much product on the brush, making it impossible to apply it properly. The lashes stick together, dry quickly, and it's difficult to comb them with another brush. I won't even mention the cheap packaging. I have used Vivienne Sabo and XXL from some Belarusian manufacturer, and their price is 100 UAH lower, but the quality is the same as this one.

I am completely blown away by this mascara! It is incredibly waterproof. Just two days ago, I found myself caught in a massive snowstorm, and I was absolutely petrified that it would ruin my makeup since I had an important meeting coming up. However, much to my astonishment, this mascara didn't smudge even a tiny bit! Moreover, it lasts for a long time. I purchased it three months ago and have been using it every day, and it only ran out today. I am definitely going to buy it again! I wholeheartedly recommend it to everyone, without any hesitation.

I did not like the mascara. Firstly, it arrived without any packaging (as if it had been unpacked and returned). Secondly, the mascara itself had clumps. And thirdly, the brush sticks all the lashes together, and as for lengthening, it is completely absent. Money wasted in vain. I have never seen such a mascara before, very disappointed. One star for the beautiful design of the tube.

This mascara is amazing. Probably the best one I've ever tried. It perfectly coats the lashes and makes the eyes very expressive. It is super long-lasting when worn, but also comes off easily when removed (which is very convenient). I would gladly order it again.