Gosh Catchy Eyes Waterproof Mascara Lash Mascara

The mascara is quite thin in consistency. It doesn't add volume to the lashes, but it does make them more vibrant. However, it may smudge immediately after application. Removing it with my regular waterproof makeup remover is quite difficult.

I liked the mascara. It applies smoothly while fresh. If it dries after application, it doesn't smudge or flake. It applies nicely.

The mascara did not live up to expectations, it is not long-lasting at all, smudges and smears during wear throughout the day!

The mascara does not deliver on its promised qualities. It is not even waterproof, as it smudges simply by running a finger over it. I tried it on my eyebrows first, and after an hour, I ran my finger over them and everything smudged. The same thing happened on my eyelashes. In the photo, you can see a dry stick that I used to wipe off the smudged mascara.

This product does a great job of coating the eyelashes, without clumping or creating the "spider leg" effect. The brush is also convenient to use. However, it provides a natural look without adding volume or length. It holds up excellently on oily skin in hot weather. It is also easily removed with waterproof makeup removers. Unfortunately, it turned out to be allergenic for me. It was the first time I had a reaction to a cosmetic product, resulting in swollen red eyelids.

The mascara is really good, I liked its consistency. It goes on the brush smoothly without any clumps. Each eyelash gets individually coated, without sticking together. By the end of the day, there are no dark circles under the eyes.

So far, the best waterproof mascara I've tried in this price range. The brush initially seemed uncomfortable, but I quickly learned to separate my lashes with it. It dries in about a minute, but then it doesn't smudge or flake. I constantly wear a mask at work in the hospital, so I no longer buy non-waterproof mascaras. It easily removes with Garnier Skin Naturals micellar water with oils. I will be ordering more.

Being a fan of the classic pink mascara from this line, I had been dreaming of finding a waterproof alternative. I bought this product and was shocked to find that it is, without exaggeration, the worst mascara I have ever used. The brush seems similar to the classic one, and the texture is also similar, but it still clumps, horribly sticks lashes together, weighs them down, and does not lengthen them. Despite my efforts to get used to it for almost a month, the result was dozens of fallen lashes. It is impossible to completely remove it, no matter what I tried, without vigorous rubbing. For the first time in my life, I threw away a nearly new product. I give it two stars for the fact that you can go to the sauna and dive into the sea with this mascara without it smudging.

I read the comments and was hesitant to order this mascara as many people didn't seem to like it. However, I decided to give it a try since I had previously used Gosh mascara.
In my opinion, it's a good mascara. I used to use Gosh Catchy Eyes (the pink tube), which wasn't waterproof. Now, I'll switch to this one.
I really like the brush, it curls and lengthens my lashes without clumping them together. However, you need to apply it carefully because, like many mascaras, it can be a bit watery at first, but it thickens over time.
The mascara doesn't clump and it's quite black.
It's definitely long-lasting, as I removed it with makeup remover oil and face wash. (I used the face wash to remove the oil, and the mascara came off perfectly with the oil).
I haven't worn it throughout the whole day yet, so if there's anything else to add, I'll update my comment.
Again, I've been using Gosh mascara for a long time and I really like this type of brush. You may have your own favorite, and that's okay. I'm writing this comment for those who also love Gosh but are hesitant. Don't worry, if you liked Gosh Catchy Eyes (in the pink tube), you'll also like this one.
And one more thing, yes, it takes about 5 minutes to dry. But during that time, I do something else. If you just stand and stare in the mirror the whole time, then yes, it can feel very long.
I even tried to take a photo, but my phone honestly doesn't capture the full beauty of my lashes.

This is an excellent long-lasting mascara. It applies smoothly without clumps, and it doesn't make the lashes stick together. The lashes look very natural. It's a cool minimalist mascara that doesn't go overboard. It may not be suitable for those who prefer volume.